Swatch card No. SW-1907 · cut November 17, 2026
Sustainability & ComplianceMill spec card
GHG Protocol Scope 2 Overhaul Leaves Legacy PPA Rules Unresolved
A three-day GHG Protocol workshop settled the direction of Scope 2 electricity accounting but left transition dates, thresholds and legacy PPA recognition unresolved until a Dec. 15 board meeting.
- Fiber
- Sustainability & Compliance
- Count
- 3 min read
- Cut
- Weight
- 661 words
Spec notes
- The Oct. 20–22 workshop in Washington, D.C. gathered 39 of 46 technical working group members to reconcile more than 1,100 consultation comments.
- Hourly matching and deliverability rules will enter the final Scope 2 revisions; timelines under discussion range from 2031 to 2039.
- CEBA members have procured more than 50 GW of electricity under the current rules and risk losing credit for ongoing 15-year PPAs.
- Recommendations go to the independent standards board in early December, for consideration at a Dec. 15 meeting.
- Final revision text will circulate in Q2 2027 within a unified GHG Protocol–ISO corporate standard consultation.

A three-day workshop in late October failed to settle the questions that will decide how global brands account for purchased electricity, including whether existing renewable contracts will retain any value under new rules. The Greenhouse Gas Protocol convened its Scope 2 technical working group in Washington, D.C., and virtually from Oct. 20–22 to reconcile more than 1,100 comments submitted during its public consultation on carbon accounting revisions.
Two headline changes will survive into the final text, according to meeting notes published this week and an Oct. 16 update from the GHG Protocol's independent standards board, which holds the final say. Companies would report emissions from hourly electricity consumption rather than the annual calculation in place since 2015. New "deliverability" rules would require contracts or environmental attribute certificates to originate from the same grid regions where companies consume their power.
But the working group may soften the landing. Its recommendations propose hourly matching as "recommended" rather than "required," phased in over several years starting with the largest electricity consumers as hourly data becomes available.
What survives, and what stays open?
The workshop backed three adjustments, per the published notes:
- A phased transition beginning with the largest users by load, with "dates, thresholds and readiness conditions" still undefined. Timelines under discussion span 2031 to 2039. Companies with annual loads above 10 terawatt-hours may have to comply by 2031, for 2030 data.
- Standardized grid boundaries based on "plausible physical connection between generation and consumption," set by the GHG Protocol or an independent authority rather than interpreted company by company.
- Flexibility on incrementality, which the group wants recommended rather than required. Likely qualifying resources include clean generation contracts where the buyer is the original offtaker, or where the source is within a 15-year age limit discussed at the meeting.
Legacy contracts remain the sharpest open question. The current draft text carries a single effective date, after which all contracts must meet hourly matching, local deliverability and grid incrementality conditions. That alarms the Corporate Energy Buyers Association, whose members have procured more than 50 gigawatts of electricity under the old rules. "This means that a company that signed a 15-year PPA could lose credit for that investment while the PPA is ongoing," CEBA wrote in a blog detailing its concerns.
Subgroups and further meetings will address the outstanding issues through November. Recommendations reach the independent standards board in early December, for consideration at a scheduled Dec. 15 meeting. Final revision text will circulate in the second quarter of 2027, within a comprehensive consultation on a unified corporate carbon accounting standard jointly developed by the GHG Protocol and the International Organization for Standardization.
"The outcomes of the workshop, as reflected in the minutes, are an interim step towards a final standard which will require additional steps and public consultation," the meeting summary stated.
Who is actually deciding?
The workshop drew 39 of 46 working group members, plus guests from the standards board, the GHG Protocol secretariat and ISO. One participant questioned how much influence the group holds. "What struck me, and what may be the bigger story, is how it appears the independent standards board has already decided the major items and is using the working group to discuss more technical points," said Matthew Yamatin, a former Thermo Fisher Scientific sustainability program manager now working as an independent advisor.
The Scope 2 debate is already rippling into target-setting. The Science Based Targets initiative's Corporate Net-Zero Standard 2.0, which reshapes Scope 2 target processes, takes effect Feb. 1. SBTi is now seeking public comments on interim changes, including definitions for grid deliverability regions and clarified recognition pathways for older PPAs, to bridge the gap until the GHG Protocol's final standard lands.
For sourcing and sustainability teams, the practical task is contract review: buyers holding long-dated PPAs signed under the 2015 rules face a December decision point that could determine whether those investments still count.
via trellis.net (Source)
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in fashion industry as a trade and business at The Fabric Brief.
308 articles
Also on the board
- SBTi opens 30-day comment period on net-zero electricity rules
- M&S Pushes Renewable Electricity Into Fashion Supply Chain
- M&S Launches Re:Spark to Scale Renewable Power in Supply Chain
- Apparel Sector Falling Short on Decarbonization Pace, Report Finds
- RSWM Cuts Scope 1 Emissions 40.5% as Net Zero Bid Gathers Pace